If you’ve ever run a niche blog, you might have experienced this particular frustration: Why is it that only the most trivial, unimportant posts get all the traffic?
I’ve been there. I’ve run niche blogs in the past, and I’ve faced this exact issue. The articles I poured my heart and soul into barely got any attention, while the random, throwaway posts I wrote on a whim attracted the majority of visitors. Over time, this mismatch between effort and results wore me down, and eventually, I ended up shutting down the blog entirely.
But that’s not the only challenge that comes with running a niche blog. There’s another major risk: the difficulty of pivoting when your niche grows too broad or competitive. Since a niche blog is tightly focused on one specific theme, if that theme becomes oversaturated with competition or falls out of favor with search engines, it can be incredibly hard to recover. I’ve experienced this firsthand. One of my niche blogs saw its rankings plummet as the topic became more competitive. At that point, shifting to a new theme wasn’t feasible because the entire site was built around that one topic. Ultimately, I had no choice but to shut it down.
Reflecting on these experiences, I’ve come to feel that running a general (or “miscellaneous”) blog might be a better approach in the long run. Here are some of the key advantages of general blogs:
- Freedom to write about anything: You’re not locked into one theme, so you’re less likely to run out of ideas or lose interest.
- Flexibility to adapt: If one topic underperforms or becomes outdated, you can easily pivot to another without starting from scratch.
- Diverse content portfolio: With multiple topics covered, you’re less reliant on any single area for traffic or revenue.
Of course, general blogs aren’t without their downsides. One major drawback is that they often lack the specialization and authority required to rank highly in search engine results. This can make it harder to gain traction compared to a well-focused niche blog. However, for those who value sustainability and creative freedom over short-term gains, general blogs can be an excellent choice.
Ultimately, whether you choose a niche blog or a general one depends on your personality and goals. If you’re aiming for rapid monetization or want to establish yourself as an authority in a specific field, then a niche blog might be the way to go. But if you’re looking for something more flexible and enjoyable over the long term, a general blog could be the better option.
Personally, after my past struggles with niche blogging, I’ve decided to stick with writing general blogs. It allows me to avoid the stress of having traffic concentrated on just a few posts or being unable to adapt when circumstances change. Most importantly, it gives me the freedom to write about what truly interests me—and that’s what makes blogging enjoyable in the first place.
